trismugistus.com digital-bondage.net writing reviews links

easy nav bar

 

home

 

walls

 

writing

 

reviews

>

>

anime

 

 

manga

 

 

tv&films

 

links
 

about

trismugistus.com and digital-bondage.net are my web sites.

trismugistus.com is where I upload my anime, manga and tv&film reviews, and also where I occasionally post short stories and longer works I've written.

digital-bondage.net is my wallpaper site and provides anime, manga and other desktop wallpapers in a variety of resolutions. I also have some psds for you to download.

I also run a site called scan-city.org, which provides some scans for you to download and use in your wallpapers.

You can also read my blog here or check out my anime list here. I also have pages on devart here and urbis here.

 

steamboy review

go to details

go to opinion

go to summary

details

The Genre: science fiction

The Format: DVD

wheee!

The plot: Ray Steam is a young boy following in the footsteps of his father, Eddy , and grandfather, Lloyd, scientists dedicated to advancing technology through the use of steam. When Lloyd invents a steam ball that has unheard-of possibilities, everyone wants it--world leaders, wealthy industrialists, and even the government--but most of them want it for evil purposes. And so it is up to Ray to protect the fate of the earth while also choosing between his father and grandfather.

back to top

opinion

I've always loved steam punk.

Steampunk is similar to cyberpunk, which I think people are more familiar with. The basic idea of cyberpunk is encapsulated in the name - cyber referring to the high tech and punk referring to low-life.

In other words, cyberpunk looked at futuristic technology, but did so at the street level. It tended to feature hackers and criminals who had an intimate understanding and ability with technology pitched against huge corporations.

The Matrix has a bit of a cyberpunk feel, though something like Blade Runner is probably one of the best examples. It features advanced technology, like clones, but involves lots of running around in the grimy streets.

I generally like to think of steampunk as something like cyberpunk if it had happened in the Victorian era. There is a big difference, though - cyberpunk tends to be quite dystopian in nature, where steam punk is often quite optimistic in feel.

Steampunk is often an extrapolation of the Victorian era, where technology was perceived as having the capacity to bring good into the world, where cyberpunk is set much later down the line and the technological dream has gone bad.

As with cyberpunk the name gives you a big clue - the steam in this case generally refers to the fact that steam power was the droving engine of the industrial revolution. The common way of achieving it is to say well "what if x had or hadn't happened?"

So a good example is Charles Babbage's Difference Engine. This was essentially a binary calculator - a computer - that never really got finished and wasn't seen as being a worthwhile endeavour by people at the time. However, if you ask the question what if had been finished and people had taken it up, then you can imagine a world where the computer revolution happens a century earlier, but driven by steam.

Other questions might be what if the Hindenburg disaster hadn't killed off Dirigibles (airships)?

big balls

Steamboy is very much planted in this type of world, although it doesn't go to so much trouble in explaining quite how the world got to that state. Specifically, it's set in the run up to the Great Exhibition of 1851 in an alternate reality, with it's climax occurring on the opening day of Crystal Palace.

The steamboy of the title is Ray Steam, who is the youngest of a family of what could basically be called mad scientists. Actually think of the great Victorian engineers - Stephenson, Brunel - and mix in a bit of the traditional mad scientist and that's basically the Steam family.

The story actually kicks off because the elder steams have managed to invent something called a steamball, which, although it's never quite explained properly, seems to represent a kind of high-voltage battery crossed with a super-charger. It can apparently store steam and also achieve phenomenal pressure.

Ray's father, Eddy, injured in an accident where he and Ray's grandfather, Lloyd, were developing the steamball, goes off the deep-end a little and wants to use the steamball's phenomenal power to power something called the steam castle.

The steam castle is a huge weapon of war and is being developed by Eddy for the O'Hara foundation - the head's daughter, Scarlett is aboard and is of a similar age to Ray. The O'Hara foundation appears to be something akin to an international arms dealership that's willing to sell to anyone who can pay.

eyebrows of doom

This then forms a sub-plot because their intentions could cause the world's balance of power to shift away from the British Empire, which, slightly incongruously, brings in Robert Stephenson. Although it isn't stated, it's clear this is supposed to be roughly the real life Robert Stephenson of The Rocket fame, but in a more militaristic position.

I don't normally do plot summaries like that, but I thought it was important here to illustrate a particular point - the above sounds quite good, doesn't it?

It sounds like a ripping adventure with a bit of a social message, right? Well it sounds good, but to be totally honest it never really seems to quite live up to the potential of the ideas.

Don't get me wrong - there's plenty to like about the film. The animation is superb and the soundtrack is quite good, for example. Unfortunately the DVD was dub only, but the dub featured a host of well known names, including Patrick Stewart, so I wasn't too bothered about that.

No, what hampers it is the plotting. The pace seems wrong, and there are quite a few little inconsistencies and oddities that niggle at you, spoiling your enjoyment.

valve pr0n

A good example of this is the Scarlett girl. In this type of film you'd expect her to be the love interest. Given Ray and her ages it's fair enough that it wouldn't be a full-on romance, but here it's not really even developed in that direction.

I mean when we first see Scarlett, she's behaving in a beastly manner, which isn't that unusual in itself, but what they do is have her be really mean to her pet dog. Maybe this represents a dividing line between East and West, but someone being nasty to a dog by way of character introduction is never going to rate highly in my affection.

They then don't do a very good job at redeeming her, but, more crucially, they don't really make a good job at giving her and Ray and emotional connection either. So at the end, when she ends up in inevitable peril and he has to rescue her, you kinda don't feel the jeopardy or that he's doing it because he cares about her.

He's doing it simply because he's a good person, and to be frank that's a weaker motive.

Another example is a letter that Ray writes to his mother. Basically he writes her a letter and then Scarlett mentions its contents to him, which she could only have seen by opening it and reading it.

But he doesn't get angry at this. Instead he asks his father and he says something to the effect that he sent Ray's letter and that he's been sending letters himself.

And that's it. It's not really clear if Eddy is lying, or Scarlett stole the letter or what. But importantly, Ray doesn't really seem to care either way, so all you're ending up with is just some random weird bit that doesn't make sense.

Which is the problem of the film generally - the ideas are good, the production is sumptuous, but too many bits either don't make sense or aren't handled in an effective manner, and it spoils the film overall.

back to top

summary

The Summary: Steam punk gets a lavish production, it's a shame that the story isn't on a similar par.

The Score: 3/5

The Pictures:

(click for larger versions)

click for full-size image

back to top

home | reviews | anime

affiliates

 

friends

uk-a
animepaper
devart
urbis
MAL
 

my sites

trismugistus.com
digital-bondage.net
scan-city.org
 

my stuff

trigs@AP
trigs@devart
trigs@urbis
my blog
my anime list
 
babe
 

v5 © Mark Sunderland