trismugistus.com digital-bondage.net writing reviews links

easy nav bar

 

home

 

walls

 

writing

 

reviews

>

>

anime

 

 

manga

 

 

tv&films

 

links
 

about

trismugistus.com and digital-bondage.net are my web sites.

trismugistus.com is where I upload my anime, manga and tv&film reviews, and also where I occasionally post short stories and longer works I've written.

digital-bondage.net is my wallpaper site and provides anime, manga and other desktop wallpapers in a variety of resolutions. I also have a few tutorials and some resources, such as psds for you to download.

I also run a site called scan-city.org, which provides scans from the latest japanese anime magazines for you to download and use in your wallpapers.

You can also read my blog here or check out my anime list here.

 

mahoromatic review

go to details

go to opinion

go to summary

details

The Genre: Comedy/Sci-fi/Romance

The Format: 12 episodes across 3 disks from ADV

tee hee hee, as it were

The plot: Suguru's horrible cleaning skills have his friends calling his home the "haunted house," and being an orphan, he needs help! Enter Mahoro, a beautiful 19 year old who catches bullets with her fingers, claims to be an android and who wants to be his maid! Mahoro is a combat android who has a choice - her existence will end in 37 days if she continues to fight - or she can become a maid for an orphaned teen and live for 398 more days! Now, Suguru's school friends are suspicious and his well-endowed teacher is going over the edge with jealousy. How will he react when he discovers that she only has 398 days to live and that she has chosen him for a reason?

back to top

opinion

If I was to admit to you that I’m a Gainax fanboy, would you hold it against me?

I mean I’m a huge fan of Eva, FLCL and all, but I think my fanboy-ness was really kicked off Wings of Honneamise. I loved that film.

It was like proper sci-fi in a period where all that seemed to be available for us sci-fi geeks was huge, badly animated space battles and naff mecha shows. Don’t get me wrong, I like a good huge space battle and robots pounding on each other, but they’re not proper sci-fi.

Proper sci-fi is about exploring questions. Questions like “What if?” or “Why?” are favourites, but it’s also about exploring more complicated current day issues and extrapolating them into the future to make a point.

I’m digressing somewhat, but it is relevant to a degree. There’s more sci-fi in Mahoromatic than it might initially appear. This show comes across very much as a romantic comedy with a good portion of fan-service thrown in for good measure. Nothing particularly daring there then, but underneath there are some strong sci-fi elements that for me add a greater level of interest.

Mahoro is a combat Android built by the Saint organisation. This seemingly private, or possibly pseudo-governmental organisation has apparently been tasked with keeping the Earth safe from a bunch of aliens. And for some reason or another, the battles with the aliens are sort of stage-managed.

don't cry hon, they're only nipples

That’s not the right phrase – what I mean is the aliens don’t appear to be interested in an all-out assault on Earth, but instead send small groups of androids to attack or undertake specific, small-scale missions. It’s more like formalised duelling than actual invasion.

However, Mahoro has come near to the end of her operational life and is essentially given the opportunity to retire. She chooses to live out her days as a maid for one Suguru Misato. This is getting into classic Japanese romantic territory - she enters into servitude; they fall in love, etc, etc.

But that’s not what’s going on at all. She chooses to look after Suguru because he is the orphaned son of her former commander, whose death she was instrumental in. So really it’s all about commitment, loyalty, respect and things like that. She feels a sense of responsibility for this boy, as well as a kind of maternal instinct.

So there we have it, in essence. An interesting set up, but then things play out in a fairly predictable, formulaic way each episode, right?

lolz

Well not really, no. Here again, Mahoromatic manages to pull something of a rabbit out of its hat. It doesn’t keep recycling the same gags and set-ups over and over again (well okay, some gags are re-used a fair bit, but we’re not talking Love Hina here). Indeed, some episodes have almost no comedy in them, whilst others are entirely humorous. Some episodes lack action, whilst others are romps from beginning to end.

The series therefore manages to stay fresh and interesting from beginning to end.

And while I’m on the subject of the end, I should probably put my main criticism of this series on the table. It doesn’t end properly.

Seriously, you’ll get to the end of the third disk and think to yourself “And...? So what happens now, then?” Why it does this is because it’s essentially only half of a full series.

I don’t know if it was because the money ran out, or they got commissioned for a second series half way through, or even that it was planned this way, but you can watch the first and second series right-through like a single, twenty-odd episode series and not realise it’s two separate things.

booblies!

Unfortunately, at this time only the first series is on release in the UK, so let's hope we get the second one sometime soon. The problem with this is it’s frustrating. When I watch a TV series like this, I like to watch them in a single chunk. I don’t mean I watch it all in one day, necessarily, but maybe over the course of a week I watch it through, and that’s all that’s on my DVD player.

In the case of anime I then watch the dub version in the next week (or highlights off if it’s an appalling dub) and maybe start formulating a review sometime in the following month. Then it’s a case of scanning the covers, building up the web page from the bits and pieces and putting it in the update queue.

So when I watched this series I did so with a kind of mounting annoyance. There’s not enough of it. I was left so gagging for more I was almost tempted to buy the US version of the second series. (I didn’t, I watched my fansubs of the second series instead, but you get the point.)

Still, what’s there is very good, and I really can’t fault any of it.

Mind you, I don’t think it’ll be everyone’s cup of tea. You should be aware that if you really don’t like romantic comedy it's a very strong element to the show. Similarly if the very thought of fan-service makes you seethe with rage or disgust,r it’s best avoided.

But for normal people you should enjoy it... And then send a letter of impatient annoyance to ADV demanding they acquire the sub-licence for the second part off of Pioneer.

Well, just one last thing to cover – the package itself. Whilst it’s not exactly crammed with extras, the episode count is decent enough and the dub is of a reasonable standard. The show looks excellent and a high production value is clear throughout, both on the original Japanese side as well as the US version, which this is simply a R2 release of.

back to top

summary

The Summary: Mahoromatic is perfectly pitched and paced to deliver exactly what it sets out to from the very first minute to the last.

The Score: 5/5

The Pictures:

(click for larger versions)

cover 1

cover 2

cover 3

back to top

home | reviews | anime

friends

uk-a
animepaper
devart
urbis
 

my sites

trismugistus.com
digital-bondage.net
scan-city.org
 

my stuff

trigs@AP
trigs@devart
trigs@urbis
my blog
my anime list
 
babe
 

v5 © Mark Sunderland